by Rich Lindgren, CPP - Chainalytics
Mullen Burst tested board had long been the industry standard for grading corrugated board for secondary and tertiary packaging, (aka Shipping cases). As corrugators started utilizing more and more recycled content in their corrugated board, it was discovered that recycled board of the same basis weight did not always perform as well in the Mullen Burst test but still had some very good vertical compression qualities.
Somewhere along the line, ECT (Edge Crush Test) was developed as another method of grading corrugated board. The Mullen Burst test pressures a rubber diaphragm bubble against the board in a defined area to measure the pounds of pressure per square inch to burst the board. The ECT test takes a defined sample board size and measure the straight compression force for that sample size.
 |
| ECT vs Burst Comparative Compression Value Chart |
So if all you do in straight column stacks of product, that does not bulge out against your container and store in controlled environments, you should see very similar performance between ECT & Burst. On the hand, most companies do not have these ideal conditions, and handle & restack their boxes many times within their own distribution channels. And we all know the distribution hazards of shipping in a single parcel environment through UPS or Fedex can also wreak havoc on your packaging design and may require different materials or a different protective packaging strategy.
In this case, you should see much better overall box performance from the Mullen Burst board because of the configuration and natural strength of their longer fibers. You can also combine Mullen weight papers with traditional ECT papers to help offset costs and still create a better box. This is still relatively uncommon due to the special paper combinations and high volumes needed.
In summary, sometimes ECT is the right choice and saves money, but many times the ECT will cost you in the long run with increased damage and customer dissatisfaction.
If it all seems like too much to digest, or if you need help with distribution packaging solutions, let the Packaging Engineers at Chainalytics help you out!
Packaging@Chainalytics.com
This is a great article and it elaborates as well as describe very comprehensively about the difference between a corrugated packaging and an E.C.T.This article is very informative and too worthwhile as well.
ReplyDeleteA great article. Thank you for the awesome information
ReplyDeleteHi, What if I tell my vendor to make carton only on ECT basis and not the BS? Will that affect the strength quality/ pricing or other parameters?
ReplyDeleteECT board is often less expensive the Burst grade board, from a compression strength they are often very close in peformance, but when it comes to drops, bulge, rough handling the Burst board out performs the ECT boards
DeleteGreat Article.... Is there any formula through which we can relate these two terms?
ReplyDeleteThis is a great article, and confirms what I've observed all along. The problem is however, the box companies seem to go out of their way to force ECT on everyone.
ReplyDeleteFrank -
ReplyDeleteI have observed the same. Most corrugated Sales reps really don't know the difference & sell on price, so they are going to go with ECT almost every time. Also, ECT has become so much more common and prevalent for many plants, Burst grade paper becomes a specialty item for them.
Thanks for the comment!
Rich